The proposal raises questions over irregular refugees' access to legal remedies, independent monitoring and accountability for potential human rights violations in Rwanda.
The UN human rights chief is "concerned about the human rights risks" over announced plans of five European countries to establish a return hub in Rwanda, a spokesperson has said.
Responding to Anadolu's question during a UN briefing in Geneva on Tuesday, Marta Hurtado said the office had not yet seen the text of the proposal.
"While we are not privy to the text of the proposal itself, the High Commissioner (Volker Turk) is concerned about the human rights risks raised by this proposed transfer of people from five European countries to Rwanda, where they have no genuine connection, and which has its own set of human rights challenges," Hurtado said.
Asked whether the office could monitor human rights safeguards and what accountability mechanisms might be needed, Hurtado said a fuller response would follow.
"We will be issuing our more detailed response shortly," she said.
The remarks came a day after Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece, and the Netherlands announced that they were jointly exploring a return hub arrangement with Rwanda, aiming to reach an agreement and initiate the first transfers by 2027.
According to the governments' joint statement on Monday, the proposed hub would accommodate irregular asylum seekers who do not have legal permission to remain in the five countries and who are subject to enforceable return or removal decisions.
The governments said the arrangement would comply with "EU, Rwandan and international law," including international human rights law.
Under European and international human rights law, transfers must comply with the principle of non-refoulement, which prohibits sending people to places where they face persecution, torture, or other prohibited treatment.
The proposed arrangement also raises questions regarding access to legal remedies, independent monitoring, and which authorities would be accountable for potential human rights violations after irregular refugees arrive in Rwanda.
Under the proposed model, migrants would have an opportunity to integrate into Rwandan society or voluntarily travel to their countries of origin or another country where they could legally reside.
In a separate statement on Monday, the International Organisation for Migration (IOM) said it could provide operational support at Rwanda's request if its mandate and international standards were upheld.
It stressed that it would not participate in "forced removals, detention, law enforcement or security functions," and that its assistance would begin only after migrants arrived.
UN High Commissioner for Refugees Barham Salih, who attended the Vienna meeting, emphasised the need for fair asylum procedures, humane returns, and compliance with international refugee and human rights law. The agency said it had agreed to provide advice to help ensure those standards were upheld.
Rwanda previously agreed to receive asylum seekers under a British government scheme, but the UK’s Supreme Court ruled the arrangement unlawful in November 2023.
The judges found substantial grounds for believing that there was a “real risk of refoulement” due to deficiencies in Rwanda’s asylum procedures.
Although the European proposal differs from the British arrangement, which involved sending asylum seekers abroad for their claims to be processed, governments must still assess the safety of transfers and the protections available after arrival.
TRT World / َAA — TRT World / َAA
Photo: Reuters

