A project can be bankable for investors yet economically damaging for the host country, particularly when financing arrangements reproduce historical patterns of economic extraction, allowing former colonial powers to capture the returns.

NEWSTIMETR
NEWSTIMETR
The economics the World Bank must confront on gas

A project can be bankable for its investors and economically damaging for the country hosting it. This is particularly concerning when financing arrangements reproduce historical patterns of economic extraction, in which former colonial powers capture investment returns while African countries shoulder long-term financial and environmental liabilities.

The 2026 World Bank and IMF Annual Meetings in Bangkok took place against an uncomfortable reality: developing countries are being asked to grow faster while carrying more expensive debt, absorbing volatile energy prices and navigating a financial system that still prices African development as an exceptional risk.

Private capital mobilisation, job creation and economic resilience dominated the agenda. Yet the way Africa's energy future is being financed works against all three. We cannot call for fiscal discipline and affordable energy while encouraging another generation of infrastructure tied to volatile fossil fuel markets.

World Bank President Ajay Banga has made job creation and private investment central to the Bank's development strategy. The Bank reports that private capital mobilisation reached a record $112 billion in the 2026 financial year, including about $22 billion in Africa.

But mobilising finance and delivering development are not the same thing. Capital must be judged by what it produces, the liabilities it creates and who pays when commercial assumptions fail.

For Africa, this also means asking whether such investments strengthen the continent's productive capacity. Energy financing should not simply expand electricity supply; it must enable African industries to manufacture, process raw materials and capture greater value domestically.

Otherwise, we risk mobilising billions in capital while reinforcing an economic model in which Africa supplies resources and consumes what others produce. The real measure of development finance must be its contribution to Africa's industrial transformation.

The financing model is part of the problem

Our new report, Unpacking the 'bridge fuel' myth: Why fossil gas is bad economics for the Global South, published by Recourse with Africa Change Lab and The Big Shift Global, examines the economic risks hidden beneath the language of energy security and transition fuels.

Gas infrastructure requires substantial upfront investment, long repayment periods and dependable revenue streams. Pipelines, liquefied natural gas terminals and gas-fired power stations frequently depend on long-term purchasing commitments to satisfy lenders.

Across Africa, these financing contradictions are increasingly evident. In Namibia, the long-delayed Kudu gas-to-power project illustrates the commercial uncertainty surrounding gas investments and their dependence on public support.

In South Africa, the failure of the first 2,000 MW gas-to-power procurement round to award capacity raises questions about commercial viability and infrastructure costs. In Nigeria, the World Bank provided $400 million in partial risk guarantees for gas supply arrangements, yet implementation delivered limited results.

Together, these cases expose a fundamental contradiction: private investments are made bankable through public risk protection, while their developmental returns remain uncertain. Development finance must prioritise productive value creation rather than transferring commercially questionable risks onto African public balance sheets.

South Africa exposes the contradiction

South Africa's proposed LNG infrastructure would introduce substantial exposure to internationally priced fuel while electricity revenues remain largely rand-denominated. Currency depreciation could therefore increase operating costs independently of domestic electricity demand.

The financial consequences would ultimately reach Eskom, the Treasury or consumers through tariffs.

Research by Meridian Economics has already challenged the competitiveness of gas-fired generation against alternative electricity-system investments.

Yet the proposed gas pathway requires infrastructure that could lock South Africa into long-term payment obligations precisely when renewable generation, storage and grid investment offer opportunities to reduce fuel-price exposure.

This is particularly troubling in a country already struggling with electricity affordability, industrial competitiveness and constrained public finances.

The recently launched Beyond Gas Campaign Toolkit for South Africa, developed by Africa Change Lab, responds to this challenge by strengthening public engagement, evidence-based advocacy and accountability around proposed gas investments.

It challenges the assumption that more fossil infrastructure automatically means economic development.

Namibia and the illusion of resource wealth

In Namibia, the report points to delayed fiscal revenues, investor cost recovery and a weak link between offshore extraction and domestic industrialisation.

Offshore petroleum discoveries may increase headline GDP without proportionately increasing domestic value creation.

Foreign operators can recover substantial development costs before governments receive meaningful fiscal returns. Meanwhile, export-oriented extraction does not automatically deliver affordable electricity, local manufacturing or broad-based employment.

For Namibia, the opportunity cost is considerable. Capital and institutional attention devoted to speculative fossil infrastructure could instead support domestic renewable generation, transmission, storage and industries capable of retaining more economic value.

Resource sovereignty cannot be measured by the volume extracted. It must be measured by the economic capabilities a country develops and retains. The report finds the same risks in its other case studies: Bangladesh, Pakistan and Nigeria.

What development finance should actually deliver

The World Bank Group should stop financing fossil gas, directly and indirectly. That includes guarantees, MIGA cover, IFC lending through financial intermediaries, development policy finance and technical assistance that builds gas markets.

Its finance should instead go to concessional lending, local-currency instruments, transmission and risk-sharing that lowers the final cost of electricity. It should judge investments on jobs, productivity, affordability and fiscal exposure, not on financial close alone.

Electricity access without affordable use delivers little economic transformation. A connection becomes development when households can use electricity sustainably and businesses can convert it into productive activity.

For African economies, electrification must support manufacturing, mineral processing, agricultural value chains, battery industries and locally owned enterprises.

These are investments that expand economic complexity rather than reproduce dependence on imported fuels and externally controlled infrastructure.

The Bangkok meetings reinforced the urgency of mobilising capital. But Africa's development future cannot be determined by the quantity of finance mobilised alone.

A project can be bankable for its investors and economically damaging for the country hosting it. This is particularly concerning when financing arrangements reproduce historical patterns of economic extraction, in which former colonial powers such as Britain, France and other industrialised economies capture investment returns while African countries shoulder long-term financial and environmental liabilities.

The risk is that Africa's energy transition becomes another mechanism for transferring wealth outward rather than building productive capacity at home.

Africa needs an economic foundation capable of delivering affordable electricity, productive industries, decent employment and lasting fiscal resilience.

Disclaimer: The views expressed by the author do not necessarily reflect the opinions, viewpoints and editorial policy of TRT Afrika.

TRT Afrika / Dean Bhekumuzi Bhebhe — TRT Afrika

#